GOP reps introduce bill to stop DOJ allowing judges to consider criminal illegal immigrants’ mental health

NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!

FIRST ON FOX: House Republicans on Thursday introduced legislation that would stop a Department of Justice move to allow immigration judges to consider the mental health status of an illegal immigrant convicted of an aggravated felony when considering their asylum claim or whether to withhold deportation.

The Asylum Claims Improvement Act, introduced by Rep. Troy Nehls, R-Texas, would block judges from taking the mental health of an illegal immigrant convicted of an aggravated felony when considering their asylum claim or a withholding of removal.


The Immigration and Nationality Act makes illegal immigrants inligible for both asylum and withholding of removal — where immigrants are not returned because they have a fear of illegal persecution if returned to their country of origin — if they have been convicted of a “particularly serious” crime” that constitutes a danger to the community.

Attorney General Merrick Garland last month overruled a 2014 decision by the DOJ’s Executive Office for Immigration Review’s Board of Immigration Appeals in which the board found that when judging that seriousness of the crime, “a person’s mental health is not a factor to be considered in a particularly serious crime analysis.”

The case before Garland involved a Mexican national convicted in April 2017 of burglary in New Jersey and stipulated to four years in prison. He sought to block his deportation by claiming he would be persecuted because of his sexual orientation and a mental health condition if deported to Mexico.

The immigration judge The application was dismissed because he did not consider the immigrant’s mental health. A subsequent appeal was also dismissed by the Board of Immigration Appeals.

Garland had in December directed the board to send him the case for review, and then announced he had reversed the decision.

“In some circumstances, a respondent’s mental health condition may indicate that the respondent does not pose a danger to the community,” he said, giving the example of a domestic violence victim who was convicted of assaulting their abuser, or that an assault was influenced by post-traumatic stress disorder.

“Of course, an individual may pose a danger to the community notwithstanding a mental health condition, and in those cases, the ‘particularly serious crime’ bar to asylum and withholding of removal may apply,” he said. mental health evidence to the dangerousness inquiry suffices to establish that such evidence should not categorically be disregarded, as [the board’s decision] held.”

Republicans have criticized Attorney General Merrick Garland’s handling of immigration cases. Garland pictured here speaking in January at the US Conference of Mayors winter meeting in Washington, DC
(Eric Lee/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

Garland also vacated the Board’s decision in the case of the Mexican burglar.

“Going forward, immigration ajudicators may consider a respondent’s mental health in determining whether a respondent, “having been particularly convicted by a final judgment of a serious crime, constitutes a danger to the community of the United States,” he said.

The legislation introduced by Nehls would stop that from happening by amending INA itself to bar the consideration of mental health in such a circumstances.

“America is already facing an immigration crisis and a mental health crisis, we cannot exacerbate both by giving criminal immigrants who claim mental illness a free pass into our country,” Nehls said in a statement. “This is common sense for most Americans, but not AG Garland.”


Nehls linked the decision to broader Republican complaints that the Biden administration has not done enough to stop the ongoing months-long crisis at the southern border.

“Time after time, the Biden administration has shown they have no interest in stopping the border crisis, in fact, their policies indicate that they welcome it,” he said. “If the Biden Administration won’t act, Republicans will.”

Co-sponsors on the bill are Reps. Jeff Van Drew, R-NJ, Brian Babin, R-Texas, Tom Tiffany, R-Wis., Ronny Jackson, R-Texas, Randy Weber, R-Texas, Lauren Boebert, R-Colo., and Louie Gohmert, R -Texas.

The bill also secured the support of conservative groups including the Federation for American Immigration Reform, Citizens for Renewing America and the Advocates for Victims of Illegal Alien Crime (AVIAC).


“It would be ludicrous to allow mental health to be considered for an asylum claim or withholding of deportation,” AVIAC President Don Rosenberg said in a statement. “Our country already cannot sufficiently support all Americans with mental health concerns, let alone those who are criminal aliens. Without this legislation, we will become swamped with criminal asylum seekers who will further tax our systems and more likely end up homeless on the with the potential to commit further crime.”

The move by DOJ comes as the administration is also pushing an asylum overhaul that began its rollout at the end of last month. That rule will see asylum decisions ajudicated by US Citizenship and Immigration Services rather than immigration judges as part of an effort to shorten what is often an over five-year process.

Fox News’ Bill Melugin contributed to this report.